You Can Now Comment on Instagram Stories: How It Works & Why It Matters (2025)

You Can Now Comment on Instagram Stories

Instagram just made Stories more… social.

Until now, you could only interact with Stories by:

• Sending a private reply (which landed in the creator’s DMs), or
• Dropping a quick Story like

With the latest update, you can now publicly comment on Instagram Stories. Comments appear on the Story itself and are visible to everyone who can view that Story. It’s a big shift from “1:1 reactions in DMs” to more community-style Story conversations.

There are some important rules and limitations though, especially around who can comment and how long comments last. Let’s walk through how Instagram Story comments work, how to use them, and what this means for creators and brands.

What are Instagram Story comments and how do they work?

Instagram’s new Story comments feature lets followers post text comments under your Stories that are:

• Public – visible to everyone who can view that Story
• Ephemeral – they disappear after 24 hours, when the Story expires
• Mutual-only by default – in most rollouts, only followers you follow back (mutuals) can comment, to reduce spam and trolling

A few key details:

• If you save a Story as a Highlight, the Story comments can remain visible in that Highlight, not just for 24 hours.
• Comments sit on the bottom of the Story frame, above the controls, similar to live chat on Instagram Live.
• Creators can toggle Story replies / comments in their settings and even disable comments on a per-Story basis.

If you don’t want Story comments at all, you can switch back to the “classic” setup where people can only interact via private replies or likes.

‍

How to comment on an Instagram Story (step-by-step)

If you have access to the feature, here’s how to comment on Instagram Stories:

1. Open the Story you want to comment on.
2. Tap the chat icon in the bottom-left corner.
3. Type your comment.
4. Tap Post.

Your comment will now appear publicly on that Story for anyone in the allowed audience to see, and it will disappear when the Story does (after 24 hours), unless the Story is saved as a Highlight.

Note: If you don’t see the comment field, it may mean Story replies are disabled for that account, or you’re not a mutual follower.

Why Story comments matter for creators & brands

On paper this is “just another feature”, but in practice it changes how people interact with your Stories.

1. Stories become community spaces, not just broadcasts

Before: Stories felt like one-to-one streams — people reacted or replied privately.

Now: Story comments make them feel more like mini discussion threads that everyone can see:

• Followers can react to each other’s comments
• You can reply publicly to top questions or jokes
• It adds a “live chat” layer even on pre-recorded Stories

For creators, this is huge for parasocial depth and “I feel like I’m in the room” energy.

2. More engagement signals → better Story distribution

Public comments give Stories an extra engagement type beyond views, likes, and DM replies.

Platforms rarely spell out the algorithm in detail, but it’s safe to assume:

• Stories with more engagement (taps, likes, replies, comments) are strong signals for relevance
• That can help your Stories show earlier and more often in the Story tray for your followers

So even if comments are limited to mutual followers, they still add valuable interactions that can help nudge your content in the right direction.

3. Safer by design: mutual-only comments

Instagram has intentionally restricted who can comment, at least in the default version:

• Only mutual followers (people you follow back) can comment on your Stories
• You can control Story replies in Settings → Privacy → Story to limit or disable them

This helps keep Story comments more intimate and protected compared to open post comments, and reduces:

• Drive-by trolling
• Spammy bots
• Off-topic comments from randoms

6 ways to use Instagram Story comments strategically

You don’t have to treat Story comments as just “nice to have.” You can design Stories that earn meaningful comments.

Ask explicit questions

1. “What do you think about this?”
2. “Comment ONE word that sums up your 2025 goal.”
3. “Which version would you pick – A or B?”

Run lightweight Story debates

1. Share a hot take and invite public comments — it becomes a mini panel in your Stories.

Collect ideas and feedback

1. Ask for Q&A topics, product feedback, menu suggestions, or content requests via story comments instead of anonymous boxes.

Highlight the best comments

1. Screenshot standout comments and reshare them in future Stories (with permission if needed) as social proof or testimonials.

Use comments to spot super-engaged followers

1. People who comment repeatedly on Stories are likely your warmest audience — great candidates for future launches, betas, or invites.

Move deeper conversations to DMs

1. When a comment becomes a lead, a sensitive topic, or a detailed question, reply with:
“I’ll DM you the details 😊”
2. Then take it into DMs, where Inrō can help automate follow-up and segmentation.

Comments vs DMs: which matters more for growth?

Short answer: both, but with different roles.

Story comments are best for:

• Visible community building
• Social proof (“look how many people are reacting”)
• Light, low-stakes interactions

Story DMs are best for:

• Private questions (pricing, personal situations, logistics)
• Sales and bookings
• Nurturing leads over time

That’s why it’s smart to design Stories that invite both:

• “Comment below if you agree 👇” → drives public engagement
• “DM me ‘PLAN’ if you want the full breakdown” → funnels serious people into DMs

From there, Inrō can:

• Auto-reply to Story DMs with links/resources
• Tag people based on the keyword they used
• Drop them into DM sequences around launches, events, or offers

Story comments warm people up and give your Stories life. DMs (plus automation) help you actually convert that attention.

‍

Try Inrō to boost your Instagram growth and sales.

Attract more leads, target them with DM campaigns, and automate your interactions on Instagram!

Start for free

‍

‍

FAQ: Instagram Story comments

1. Who can comment on my Instagram Stories?

By default, Instagram only allows mutual followers (people you follow back) to comment on your Stories. This reduces spam and keeps conversations more personal. You can also adjust Story reply settings in Settings → Privacy → Story to limit or disable replies/comments.

2. Are Story comments public or private?

Story comments are public — everyone who can view that Story can see them. This is different from Story replies, which land in your DMs and are only visible between you and the person replying.

3. How long do comments on Stories last?

Story comments last as long as the Story itself: 24 hours. When the Story disappears, so do the comments. If you save that Story to a Highlight, the comments can remain visible with it.

4. Can I turn off comments on my Stories?

Yes. You can:

• Turn off replies/comments for Stories globally in Settings → Privacy → Story, or
• Disable comments on specific Stories when posting them

You can also delete individual comments that break your community rules or Instagram’s Community Guidelines.

5. Can I hide my own comments on someone else’s Story?

No. If you comment on someone’s Story, that comment is public to everyone who can see that Story. If you prefer private interaction, send a DM reply instead of using the public comment field.

6. Do Story comments affect the algorithm?

Instagram doesn’t give exact formulas, but public comments are a strong engagement signal, just like likes, saves, and replies. More engagement generally helps your Stories perform better with the algorithm and stay top of mind in your followers’ Story tray.

‍